I have concurrent 15-20 minute city surveys out right now both for inhabitants of the city of Warsaw and the city of Edinburgh.
It’s really interesting to note thus far (there are questions where respondents are able to leave comments as well), that generally, Warszawa residents responding to the survey are less critical of the idea, with most also responding that either they experience this at their local neighborhood level or would like to.
Responses from Edinburgh vary on a much wider spectrum with many respondents thus far saying they do experience this or they would really like to, as well as some commenting that they don’t like the idea of having their movement restricted.
Note on ‘Freedom of Movement‘
It’s important to note that nobody is trying to restrict people’s freedom of movement and that a 15-20 minute city or neighborhood lifestyle simply means that instead of having to commute 45 minutes in a car across town for your kid’s doctor appointment, or 30 minutes the other way for some other amenity, that generally all the ‘basic functions’ are available in your local neighborhood.
I have worked in very marginalized inner-city communities in the USA that were essentially food deserts, without a grocery store, pharmacy, clinic or many other basic amenities for blocks upon blocks.
It’s irrational and cruel to accept that people in their neighborhood do not have basic services available to them, while ‘well-to-do’ areas have a wealth of choice. This also negatively affects the overall health of the broader community.
It’s important to stress the social, health, environmental, economic and quality-of-life benefits this type of proximity and accessibility to diverse amenities and service can provide a community and its members in general but also, in particular, those who are often rather dependent on local services including many retired and elderly individuals, mobility impaired individuals, families with young children and more. Developing this concept with spatial equity and community needs in mind is crucial.
Looking forward to my first remote ‘Mobility Thought Lab‘ with residents of Edinburgh on Monday!
‘
